Classic Cheese Toastie
Light Bites British

Classic Cheese Toastie

The ultimate comfort snack, a golden toasted sandwich with a molten cheesy middle. The tiers climb from a simple pan toastie to an artisan three-cheese, cultured-butter melt with caramelised onions.

Serves2
Time17 min
Cost / serving£1.70
Vegetarian Nut-free

Make it your way

Pick a tier — the ingredients, method and cost update instantly.

Better version

Sourdough with mature cheddar and red Leicester, fried in real butter with a touch of mustard.

Per serving£1.70
Total cost£3.40
Time17 min
Classic Cheese Toastie
Servings

Ingredients for 2

  • 4 slices sourdough bread
  • 80 g mature cheddar , grated
  • 40 g red Leicester , grated
  • 30 g salted butter , softened
  • 1 tsp English mustard
  • black pepper , to taste

Method

  1. Mix the two grated cheeses together and spread a thin layer of mustard inside two of the slices.
  2. Butter the outside of every slice generously.
  3. Build the sandwiches butter-side out with the cheese mix piled in the middle, then season with pepper.
  4. Fry in a pan over medium-low heat for 4 minutes each side, pressing with a spatula, until deeply golden.
  5. Rest for a minute, then cut on the diagonal and serve.

Equipment

The three ways, side by side

Budget
£0.70 / serving · 13 min

White sliced bread, value cheddar and margarine, toasted in a pan.

Better
£1.70 / serving · 17 min

Sourdough with mature cheddar and red Leicester, fried in real butter with a touch of mustard.

Ultimate
£3.40 / serving · 32 min

Artisan sourdough with three cheeses, caramelised onions and cultured butter, finished with a Parmesan crust.